| Thief |
| You pickpocketed items worth a total of 200 coins |
| Versatile |
| You killed characters with each weapon and offensive gadget |
| Ghost |
| You completed all missions after the prologue, alerting or killing no one but key targets |
| Shadow |
| You completed all missions after the prologue without alerting anyone |
| Mostly flesh and steel |
| You finished the game without purchasing any supernatural powers or enhancements, besides Blink |
| Wall of sparks |
| You killed an enemy with the Wall of Light |
| Rogue |
| You assassinated 10 unaware enemies |
| Specter |
| After escaping prison, you completed a mission, not alerting anyone and killing less than 5 people |
| Faceless |
| After escaping Coldridge Prison, you completed a mission without alerting anyone |
| Manipulator |
| You made others kill 5 of their own allies |
| Razor Rain |
| You killed 5 characters with Drop Assassination |
| Surgical |
| You played from the first mission through Kaldwin's Bridge killing fewer than 10 characters |
| Clean Hands |
| You completed the game without killing anyone |
| Harm's Way |
| You caused 5 unintentional suicides |
| Inhabitant |
| You stayed in possession of others for most of a 3 minute period |
| Hornets' Nest |
| You killed 4 enemies in less than 1 second using the crossbow |
| Speed of darkness |
| You traveled 30 meters in less than 1 second |
| Tempest |
| You killed 6 enemies in less than 1 second |
| Merchant of disorder |
| You acquired 15 equipment upgrades |
| Art Dealer |
| You collected all the Sokolov paintings |
| Occultist |
| You collected 10 bone charms |
| The Escapist |
| After Coldridge Prison, you eluded 5 pursuers at once without killing them or leaving the map |
| Cleaner |
| You fought 5 enemies at once and none of them survived |
| Dishonored |
| You escaped Coldridge Prison |
| Excommunication |
| You eliminated High Overseer Campbell |
| Child care |
| You located Lady Emily Kaldwin, heir to the throne |
| Capturing Genius and Madness |
| You abducted Anton Sokolov, Royal Physician |
| Regicide |
| You assassinated the Lord Regent, Hiram Burrows |
| Political Suicide |
| You brought about the Lord Regent's fall from grace by broadcasting his crimes |
| This is mine |
| You recovered your belongings |
| Resolution |
| You completed the game |
| Back home |
| You grabbed a live grenade and threw it back, killing an attacker |
| Big boy |
| You killed a tallboy using only your sword |